I stayed up well past bedtime Sunday night to watch the remastered classic Trek TOS episode "Balance of Terror", newly syndicated and playing on the local CBS affiliate. I didn't make notes or anything, since I wanted to simply enjoy it, but here are my impressions after a day or two. No, I haven't seen any other reviews.
First, the episode itself was a classic submarine battle with the added tension of an unknown enemy and a crewman's suspicion about Spock's loyalty. I don't have episodes memorized, but I couldn't spot any blatant edits for time, even though the episode was certainly short.
This new reincarnation of TOS is designed to spotlight a re-recorded theme, re-mastered sound, updated effects, HD-TV resolution, and a new video processing scheme to add "depth".
On the plus side, I had no issues with the sound, even the re-recorded theme. It sounded crisp and clear, and the theme was authentic. There was something about the video that just wasn't right. It was like the contrast was way too high. The color was over-saturated. Characters had shiny foreheads and shadows looked muddy. There's the possibility that this existed somewhat in the original episode, what with it deliberately designed as a claustrophobic nail-biter where the players are supposed to look sweaty. I should probably withhold judgement on the video until I see "lighter" episodes. Also note that I watched on a standard TV.
My real issue is that the average viewer isn't going to spot a damn bit of difference in the effects. Out of timid loyalty to fanatic purists, the newly digital Enterprise still flies at weird angles, the space scenes around the bridge are still washed-out stills, and the cosmos still look pretty mundane. Perhaps because this was a ship-bound story, there may not have been the opportunity for effects wizards to show off. But then why premier with this episode? My wife is slightly more familiar with Trek than the average viewer, and her reaction was "what's different?". Even the opening looked the same. Maybe the travelling matte outlines are gone, and the ship flies a little steadier, but there was a great opportunity here to really create a buzz about a cool new "Trek enhanced". But it just looks like "Trek cleaned-up". I see no added value that would make any station want to pull this out of the late night graveyard.